the primary objectives for any futures exchange are effective price discovery and efficient price risk management. in commodity futures, it is necessary to distinguish between investment commodities and consumption commodities. an investment commodity is generally held for investment purposes whereas consumption commodities are held mainly for consumption purposes. gold and silver can be classified as investment commodities whereas oil and steel can be classified as consumption commodities.
| basis |
futures contract |
forward contract |
by definition |
futures contract is an agreement between two parties to buy or sell a specified quantity and quality of asset at a certain time in future at a certain price agreed at the time of entering into the contract on the futures exchange. |
forward contract is an agreement entered between two parties to buy or sell an asset at a future date for an agreed price. forward contract is not traded on an exchange. |
trading place |
futures contract is entered on the centralized trading platform of the exchange. |
forward contract is otc in nature. |
size of the contract |
futures contract is standardized in terms of quantity and quality as specified by the exchange |
forward contract is customized as per the terms of agreement between the buyer and seller. |
transparency in contract price |
contract price of futures contract is transparent as it is available on the centralized trading screen of the exchange |
contract price of forward contract is not transparent, as it is not publicly disclosed. |
valuation of open position and margin requirement |
in case of futures contract, valuation of open position is calculated as per the official closing price on a daily basis and ‘mark-to-market’ margin requirement exists. |
in case of forward contract, valuation of open position is not calculated on a daily basis and there is no provision of ‘mark-to-market’ margin requirement. |
liquidity |
futures contract is more liquid as it is traded on the exchange. |
forward contract is less liquid due to its customized nature and mutual trade. |
counter party risk |
in futures contract the clearing house becomes a counter party to each transaction, which is called ‘novation’, making counter party risk nil. |
in forward contract, counter party risk is high due to decentralized nature of the transaction. |
regulations |
futures contract is regulated by a government regulatory authority and the exchange. |
forward contract, is not regulated by any authority or exchange. |
settlement |
futures contract can be settled in cash or physical delivery, depending on the commodity futures contract specification. |
forward contract is generally settled by physical delivery. |
delivery |
delivery tendered in case of futures contract should be of a standard quantity and quality as per contract specifications, at designated delivery centers of the exchange. |
delivery in case of forward contract is carried out at delivery centre specified in customized bilateral agreement |